Graveyard=cemetery, right?

Arnos Vale cemetery in winter.

I spend a lot of time writing the word cemetery. I work in a historic cemetery and I am also undertaking a professional doctorate on public engagement in historic cemeteries. So its something I can define in a trice, right? Well not entirely. As with most things historical or academic you have to define your terms and sometimes this takes a fair amount of words or examples in the case of this blog. You might think a churchyard, a graveyard, a burial ground and a cemetery are the same thing, but you would be wrong.

The classic Garden Cemetery

I visit, write about and research mostly UK and Irish city cemeteries from 1819 to 1910. These burial grounds are usually called historic cemeteries or in America rural or lawn cemetery. Cemeteries from this period are often Garden Cemeteries originally laid out in field, local beauty spot or garden but they can also be found in old quarries like St James Cemetery in Liverpool, or on top of hill like Glasgow Necropolis. These cemeteries are almost always Christian in nature; either Anglican (in England), or non-conformist. There are also couple of relevant Jewish cemeteries, which I will cover separately. These cemeteries are deliberately laid out; unlike their predecessors the churchyard, graveyard or Kirk which developed organically around a central building, a central place of worship but historic cemeteries don’t have a place of worship on site. The chapel(s) on site are mortuary chapel (a place just for burial services) and not originally used for worship services, or marriages and baptisms. These chapels should not be confused with non-conformist chapels for used for worship. In fact, many of these garden cemeteries are not consecrated at all as they were set up by ‘dissenters‘ and have not been blessed by the local Anglican bishop. Some of them have sections, like Arnos Vale, that were consecrated although a few were set up as overflow cemeteries for the local church and these are generally fully consecrated. The historic cemetery movement inspired by French cemetery Père-Lachaise which is both the largest park and the largest cemetery in Paris and was built in 1804.

A place for people

It may come as a surprise to some readers but these historic cemeteries are designed for the living as well as the dead. They have wide sweeping paths, beautiful chapels, administration buildings and were usually planted with a wide range of beautiful trees, shrubs and plants. They are designed landscape with central focal points and created views that draw the eye.

Commonwealth War graves section in Locksbrook Cemetery Bath.

The father of the garden cemetery movement, John Claudius Loudon wrote his book, ‘On the laying out, planting and managing of cemeteries and on the improvement of churchyards‘ about the uses of cemeteries:

Several guide books were even produced for these cemeteries in the Victorian era, so visiting a cemetery was a leisure activity in the 19th century, see a previous blog.

So are all historic cemeteries the same?

All the historic cemeteries I have researched are different and no two are really alike. They often have a mix and match of a range of items and styles. Styles include: gothic like West Norwood Cemetery, Egyptian like Highgate Cemetery both in London, or neoclassical like Arnos Vale Cemetery.

Catacombs at Warstone Cemetery, Birmingham. Copyright David Gurney

They often feature stunning entrance ways, catacombs, columbarium and beautiful chapels. The chapels, especially at the earlier sites, are statement buildings and may well be in a specific style or a mix.

The Grade II* Samuel Worth Chapel at Sheffield General Cemetery has classical columns and design but Egyptian features reflecting its main gates.

Samuel Worth Chapel, Sheffield General Cemetery. Taken from https://www.gencem.org/thevenue

Alternatively chapels might be divided into Anglican and Non-conformist but joined in the middle with a Porte cochere like at Greenbank Cemetery in Bristol.

Planting

One of the defining features of most these historic cemeteries is the deliberate planting of specimen trees and other plants. This was to clean the air, make the place a pleasant place to visit by providing shade and as also as an arboretum for all. Abney Park in London is probably the most well known of these and was originally planted with over 2,500 varieties of plants from a scheme by George Loddiges, naturalist and gardener. Arnos Vale Cemetery was also had a wide range of planting and features native and non-native trees including Irish and English yew, monkey puzzle, willow, ash, sycamore, cherry, beech, western red cedar, holm oak and Austrian pine.

Aerial view of Ceremonial Way at Arnos Vale Cemetery, Bristol.

Other types of cemetery

So I’ve outlined the basics of a garden cemetery from the 19th century but what other cemeteries exist. The word cemetery itself comes from the Greek κοιμητήριον which means sleeping place and bodies have been buried in cemeteries for thousands of year. Kerameikos in Athens is a great example of a ancient cemetery and there is evidence it was used as early as the 3rd Century BC. Ancient Romans disposed of their dead either by burial in a cemetery outside the city walls, though at some points they cremated their dead. However in the UK cemeteries date from the 19th century. In Scotland, there are also burial grounds called Kirkyard that tend to be connected to a Kirk (or churche) and sometimes are similar to cemeteries in appearance.

Greyfriars Kirkyard, Glasgow. Copyright David Gurney

War cemetery

In the UK 19th and 20th century war dead do not have to be buried in specific war cemeteries and there are many examples of war dead in public historic or modern cemeteries. However there are a number of war cemeteries in the UK and Europe which are the last resting place of service personnel from mainly WW1 and WW2. These cemeteries are not usually open for burial to non-military personnel and in the UK most of them are run the Commonwealth War Graves commission (even if the graves are not of commonwealth member). Cannock Chase Military Cemetery is the last resting place of mainly servicemen from New Zealand and Germany, but there are a few remembered there who came from UK. There are 2 military cemeteries in Surrey: Brookwood American Cemetery which is for American service personnel only, and Brookwood Military Cemetery which is the last resting place of a number of commonwealth service personnel but also includes American, Canadian, French, Polish, Czechoslovakian, Belgian and Italian service personnel. Cambridge American Cemetery is also only for American service personnel and is run by the American Battle Monuments Commission. Wales has one dedicated military cemetery in Pembrokeshire called Pembroke Dock Military Cemetery but the cemetery is not exclusively for Welsh service personnel.

The cemetery that is closest to a historic 19th century garden cemetery is Aldershot Military Cemetery which was originally set up by the Royal Engineers in the 1850’s and nearly 17,000 service personnel of nine nations are laid to rest in the cemetery. However it is unusual because certain civilians can also be buried in the cemetery if they have a military or family connection. Although set up as a cemetery with a chapel similar to a historic garden cemetery, the chapel was originally wood which suggests it was not permeant or specifically designed like a historic cemetery. The site is laid out with neat rows but it was not particularly landscaped and was not intended to be a public green space space. It does follow the idea of a cemetery as an arboretum and although few records of its creation survive, the trees on site appear to have been planted when the cemetery was set up.

Non-Christian Cemeteries and burial grounds

During the 19th century the main faith group being buried in city cemeteries were Christian, either non-conformist (dissenter) or Anglican. However another major faith group that created cemeteries in the UK were people of the Jewish faith and according to their faith, Jewish people must be buried as soon as possible after death so its important for this community to have a suitable place that can respond quickly to this need. There are a few Jewish burial sites in the UK that were created in the 19th century and the most famous of these is Willsden Green Jewish Cemetery which was set up in 1873. The fabulous historical video on their website explains that the cemetery was set up to echo the other great Victorian cemeteries around London and that it was not like other Jewish burial places of the time. Although not conforming entirely to the standard style of the historic garden cemetery as there is no chapel. there is still a prayer hall. Another point of difference is that a Jewish Cemetery is also not designed as an arboretum as trees on or near graves are not allowed as they may disturb graves. However this Jewish Cemetery has trees and planting along the borders to provide shade and interest. Although most Jewish people were buried in Jewish cemeteries by the 19th century, there are a number of Jewish people buried in unconsecrated ground in historic cemeteries in the UK. It is also worth nothing that unlike most historic cemeteries, very few Jewish cemeteries contain cremated ashes as the Jewish law says that they should be buried in earth.

Funerary buildings at Willesden Jewish Cemetery (United Synagogue Cemetery), London, 1872-73 listed at Grade II. This cemetery is known as the ‘Rolls Royce’ of London’s Jewish cemeteries and this set of funerary buildings is a rare survival as many similar complexes in England’s Jewish cemeteries have been lost. Copyright Chris Redgrave/Historic England

There are now also Muslim burial grounds in the UK but all of these were developed after the end of the historic garden cemetery period.

Some faiths that are aligned to Christianity but are not Christian like Quaker, Johavah’s Witness, Unitarian may well be buried in standard cemeteries in unconsecrated ground. If not then they were generally buried in modest small burial areas or graveyards attached to their religious hall or chapel in the 18th and 19th century.

Modern cemeteries

I have not listed modern cemeteries in this article because these are not yet places people tend to go to for a visit. Many are very municipal in design and are designed to tended efficiently not as places to explore and enjoy ecology. Due to local council rules most monuments are very similar in height, design and style making them rather uninteresting. The buildings on site are also designed to be practical rather than attractive and are generally not architecturally appealing, though Hilary Granger does feature some outstanding examples in her book Death Redesigned: The Architecture of British Crematoria. Unlike historic cemeteries, people are not encouraged visit modern cemeteries for leisure or recreation and these sites are not designed for leisure. In addition any modern cemeteries tend to have a crematorium on site making the sites busy with mourners and visiting for leisure would be disrespectful or challenging.

So next time you come across a place of the dead, try and work out if you are in a cemetery, a graveyard, burial ground or Kirkyard.

Arnos Vale Cemetery. Copyright David Gurney

Life will find a way

The first thing most people think when they hear the word cemetery is well, dead things.  But apart from the obvious role of a cemetery, they are often thriving and full of life.  Many historic cemeteries that were established in the Victorian period were created as Garden Cemeteries.  They had a range of carefully chosen plants to enhance the look of the cemetery to invoke a botanic garden feel. Here is just a small section of Arnos Vale Cemetery showing a range of trees planted in the Victorian period including Irish Yew, cherry, Laurel, Beech and Western Red Cedar.

DO1A1564However when these sites became unloved, overcrowded and neglected, the previously carefully managed planting began to run riot.  In Arnos Vale Cemetery the trees that were grafted with ash began to merrily spread their seeds. All these spindly trees are ash or sycamore.

DO1A1440

This means that many of the young trees are ash that grow out of cracks in graves and in the spaces between.  Their roots pull up stones, widen cracks and generally cause damage. Bramble and ivy can also be invasive though a covering of foliage can protect stones from pollution. Although plants can damage old graves and memorials, these overgrown and neglected places are homes for all sorts of life.

DO1A1430

Its hard to find the balance between caring for a historic environment and ensuring green spaces are available for people and wildlife.  It is clear that in busy urban spaces, our native wildlife need historic cemeteries to survive. Butterflies and moths need bramble and nettle for their caterpillars to feed and thrive.  Our wonderful  native bats need moths to sustain them.  Foxes, hedgehogs and badgers need cover to hunt  invertebrates and small mammals.  Once answer is a landscape management plan which includes flora and fauna surveys, cutting and clearing plans and takes an overarching view of the site as a whole.

So next time you are in a cemetery or graveyard, stop and listen and look around.  You might hear the call of a sparrow hawk, spot the footprints of a deer or a badger or see the beauty of a butterfly sunning itself on a gravestone.

All pictures in this blog were taken by Super Funky Penguin Photography

A Them-Days Jamie Oliver

Originally posted on Cemetery Club:
Celebrity chefs are common-place nowadays – the likes of Gino Sheffield Di Campo, Ainsley Harriott and Jamie Oliver. But let’s turn back the clock and look at the very first ‘sleb cook whose grave is one of the most impressive funerary…

The incredibly lengthy guidebook titles of Victorian men of the better classes.

If you thought that Garden Cemetery guidebooks were a modern phenomenon, you’d be very wrong.  Since the grand tour, people have sought out the graves of the great and good and written about it.  Charles Dickens in 1844 writes of his travels in ‘Pictures from Italy’, ‘From one part of the city, looking out beyond the walls, a squat and stunted pyramid (the burial-place of Caius Cestius) makes an opaque triangle in the moonlight.  But, to an English traveller, it serves to mark the grave of Shelley too, whose ashes lie beneath a little garden near it.  Nearer still, almost within its shadow, lie the bones of Keats, ‘whose name is writ in water,’ that shines brightly in the landscape of a calm Italian night.’

“View of the Protestant Burying Ground, Rome” by Thomas Cole, probably 1833-4, Olana State Historic Site, OL.1981.17
“View of the Protestant Burying Ground, Rome” by Thomas Cole, probably 1833-4, Olana State Historic Site, OL.1981.17

The brilliant title of ‘Last Homes of Departed Genius’ from 1867 by T.P Grinsted gives an insight into why people  wanted to visit these graves; to be near to their heroes.

Writing guidebooks to graveyards and cemeteries seems to have been very popular with the clerical class, as visiting a cemetery and thinking about your own mortality was thought to be an appropriate pastime for a good Victorian Christian. The Reverend James Branwhite French described his writing of ‘Walks in Abney Park With Life- Photographs of Ministers and other Public Men whose names are found there’ as ‘loving interest in good men‘. 

To capture the interest of the crowds coming to the Great Exhibition the ‘The Christian Visitors Handbook to London’ was produced in 1851.  This listed not only churches and chapels, but suburban cemeteries that were suitable for strangers to London.  An advert of the time is shown next to a list of Sabbath Day services held in Exeter Hall.

The Christian Visitors Handbook to London printed by Partridge and Oakly 1869.jpg

These early guide books weren’t just lists of graves to hunt down, they included pictures of the deceased, maps, landscapes and biographies. Some versions went into several editions, showing their popularity. ‘Guide to Highgate’ by Percy William Justyne ran to several editions.  This may have been in part due to the beautiful images that were found in this particular guide as Justyne was an accomplished artist appearing in a range of literature and even exhibiting at the Royal Academy in 1838.

As well as visiting cemeteries to see graves, these spaces provided relief from city bustle.  Justyne wrote that Highgate had, ‘winding paths leading through avenues of cool shrubbery and marble monuments, and the groups of majestic trees casting broad shadows below, contribute to the many natural charms of this solemn region.’

Abney Park Thomas Burgess Barker 1869 front cover image.png

19th century Abney Park, a beautiful garden cemetery, had a fantastic guide book dedicated to it which is describes the landscape as a ‘beautiful depository of the dead.’ 

It wasn’t just the metropolis that had guidebooks. Many guides to Victorian city were proud to include the brand spanking new local cemetery.  A section for the these civic additions to the city with their high walls, splendid chapels and careful planting was a must. So far I’ve come across ‘A guide to the City of York’ (1848) by J Glasby, where the cemetery is mentioned on pages 149-150. Also ‘The Tourists Picturesque guide to Nottingham and its environs’ (1871) and ‘Whittys Guide to Liverpool’ (1871) mention the new place for the burial of the dead with pride. G Bishop wrote a lovely walking guide called ‘Strolls in the Brighton Extra Mural Cemetery’ which talks about the changing attitudes to cemetery visiting.

Although these new cemeteries designed for wandering and contemplating in were clearly popular with many, I’ll leave you with the rather snobbish comments by Willima Mudford writing in Bentley’s Miscellany 1841 p95, ‘I have nothing to say against your cemetery, my friend, on public grounds.  It is a public churchyard, and the public are buried here, and the public come to look at it, and a public company sells or lets out the graves for profit, and mourners weep in public, and the whole thing maybe, as I dare say, a public convenience;..

The Cemetery Lady

So this weekend I went to the amazing Cumberland Lodge in Windsor Great Park.  I was there with a mix of staff and students (undergrad to postgrad and beyond) from The University of Hertfordshire history and geography departments. This was not a conference, more of a gathering to share research in an informal atmosphere.  As part of it I shared what I am up to as part of a poster presentation.

cumberland lodge poster presentation

Within my tiny research world, people have started coming up to me and saying, ‘oh yes I remember you, you are the cemetery lady’.  Which I kind of like.  This was my first time making a poster but I’m pretty pleased with it (though I do now wish I’d added a border of skeletons).  Hopefully my research question is fairly visible at the top.

I invited people to comment on it using post-its.  I gave examples of Public Engagement and income generation activities at Arnos Vale Cemetery to help people to get thinking.  The one that raised most eyebrows was the suggestion that income generation could be by hosting weddings!

Some really great thoughts came out of the poster discussions.

Respectful use was a big thinking point and whether re-use was ever respectful.  I have always found this is a balancing act (and I’ve not always got it right in my work) and it is also site specific.  Something that may work in Arnos Vale Cemetery, is considered disrespectful in another cemetery.  Culture sensitivities are very much a factor in this.  Rules that apply in a Jewish cemetery regarding dress or visitor gender would not apply in a cemetery like Tower Hamlets, which was set up for a variety of faiths.  Digital engagement was discussed as a possible way to allow access to limited sites.

troopers hill tour

Age of a site was also an interesting factor.  I am still struggling to explain why a heritage site that is a Stone age or Iron age burial site is not really considered in the same way as a Georgian or Victorian burial site. They both contain the dead but for some reasons that I’m yet to pin down properly, one is fine to explore and visit for a day but the other is considered by some as spooky, disrespectful or weird.  I think it has to do with empathy.  It is easier to image ourselves as a Victorian than an Iron age person.  Any thoughts, links to papers etc gratefully received.

Empathy also came up as a way to engage the public though exhibitions about the lives of people remembered in a site.  This is a popular way for many cemeteries to engage visitors and generate income. The Cemetery Club is a popular London based group who run excellent tours in some of the Magnificent 7.  There was a fear expressed that the wrong sort of people could end up being celebrated by opening up sites of memorization as heritage spaces. Death cafes, contemplative spaces and memorial services were all suggested as public engagement activities.

A final discussion point was ensuring that the spaces were useful to the living.  Can and should all burial sites be saved?  What about the spaces like Cross Bones Graveyard where there are no ‘great and good’ to tell the stories of?  In the case of Cross Bones, there is strong community engagement and a different kind of story to share about the outcasts of society. How do we ensure that burial spaces aren’t just saved because of the beautiful memorials but they are also saved because of the stories they can tell?

If you’d like to please tell me your thoughts on my brain dump:

  • Should all burial sites be saved?
  • If we save them what kinds of public engagement and income generating activities do you think are appropriate?

Answers on a virtual postcard.

 

 

 

 

Let’s talk about death, baby

Death is cool now?

So according to The Guardian Death is cool.  It seems that events, news items and exhibitions exploring death, dying and human remains are popping up all over the place in UK.  It also looks like heritage and arts venues and universities are at the forefront of putting this into the public eye, working collaboratively with people directly involved with death.  Maybe it is easier for these institutions to begin the conversations because things they own, use and exhibit are all from dead people.  In 2016 Bristol Museums unveiled its massively successful exhibition ‘Death:The Human Experience‘.  Despite displaying items that might be regarded as challenging, including two boxes of human cremains (cremation ashes) and items made from human remains, the audiences and award kept coming.  The National Trust’s Sutton House also played host to Life, Death, Whatever in 2016.  This is was the month long festival featured all the usual elements that would make up a public event its theme was certainly not usual.  An event that occurs during Dying Matters Week debuted in 2017. A Matter of Life and Death by the Brum Yodo collective is hosted at Birmingham Mac and Birmingham Museum plus events in burial grounds and crematoriums.  This event encourages people to have conversations about death, dying and mortality. I was also lucky enough to attend Death and the Maiden conference hosted at the University of Winchester (which has a Death Studies department) which was amazing and inspiring.

dm-cover-e1501515080652

Obviously I need to mention Arnos Vale Cemeteries very own event Life, Death and the Rest #lifedeathrest which is happening this February. The events will encourage people to ask their questions about death and dying in a space that is perfect for these conversations.

Death positive

So why talk about death at all?  We all know we are going to die, that is the nature of the human condition.  However Freud claims, ‘in the unconscious every one of us is convinced of his own immortality’.  We fear death, in particular a bad death, so surely we should talk about it to mitigate this.  This is where the natural reticence of the British comes out.  We don’t want to upset people by talking about our demise or theirs. That’s the kindest way, right?  Well no.  Often terminally ill, people with life limiting conditions or frail elderly people want to discuss their dying and death. They want to be involved in ensuring a good death and what that means to them.  However stifling conversation with ‘don’t talk about that’ or ‘don’t be silly, you’ll be fine’ infantalises and minimises them. Talking about your own wishes for your body after death can also be incredibly helpful to loved ones.  Making your own decisions about cremation or burial, organ donation or even music at your funeral, can leave them space to grieve without worrying they’ve done the wrong thing.

AV-LDandR_logo_2018-1-e1515671434876

Talking about death won’t kill you

Hopefully I’ve begun to convince you that death and dying is ok to talk about.  If you want to think more around talking about the big D then you can’t go wrong with the great resources from The Order of the Good Death. It is a bit US-centric at times but if nothing else watch the videos to hear the amazing Caitlin Doughty which is always a treat. If you want to start a conversation try a death cafe or check out these resources 

Oh and if you want to know what I want for my funeral here’s a hint;

glass hearse

 

 

Everlasting memory

coloured immortelle

So recently I’ve been getting my head around the concept of Material Culture.

Cliff notes definition is: ‘Material culture refers to the physical objects, resources, and spaces that people use to define their culture.’ In particular I’m trying to look at objects using the J. Prown methodology from his paper Mind in Matter (1982) which involves description, deduction, and speculation.

I’ve been applying the theory to one of my favourite objects in the Arnos Vale collection.  This is an Immortelle, a wreath for placing on a grave. They were usually made of china or plaster of Paris.  They were often purchased from funeral outfitters or funeral directors. It is the more attractive (in my opinion) precursor to the plastic flowers found on modern graves. Generally these wreaths were placed on graves under a glass dome to protect them from the elements.  This one was recovered from an grave when Arnos Vale Cemetery was being cleared after its significant period of neglect.  Ironically the overgrowth of bramble and ivy probably protected this item from weather, human or animal damage.  This is the pre-lifting from the grave it was found on.

immortelle (20)

I can only imagine the excitement and confusion of the volunteer clearing the grave when they found what looked like a china flower! I keep hoping we will uncover another, but nothing yet.

With no provenance it is hard to date but it  is probably from the Edwardian era, rather than Victorian. The chunky decoration and bright colours leads me to this conclusion after taking a look at verified Victorian immortelles.   The grave it came from lists the first burial in 1884 and the last in 1915, a quite wide range to guess when it was placed!  It is unlikely to be post-WW1 as the manufacture of plastics became much better so plastic flowers were likely to be used instead on a grave.  Investigating immortelles led me briefly down a strange path exploring the surprisingly long history of fake flowers.  I was amazed to discover that the Ancient Egyptians created fake flowers using linen and horn shavings,  and the Romans used gold and silver.

The great thing about the material culture approach is summed up by Anne Gerritsen and Giorgio Riello  in the introduction to Writing Material Culture History,

Yet the people that replaced kings and queens, prime minsters and general as the subjects of history did not necessarily leave substantial written records. One of the ways in which we can trace their lives is through the material goods they left behind.’

It isn’t just the written record that can tell us about the people of the past, especially the stories of the ordinary person.  This is the person we are more likely to relate to than the ‘great and the good’ of written record.

Then of course, I had to become a part of the objects story. Here I am lifting the piece.  Yes I am aware I not wearing gloves but I decided that the sensitivity in my hands when lifting would be impaired if I wore them plus cotton or plastic may catch on the jagged edges.

immortelle (16)

This is not the only immortelle in the Arnos Vale Cemetery collection, there is another Victorian piece that is beautifully delicate but faded from weather and harsh cleaning.

white immortelle

So what do these items tell me about the people who laid them.  They mourned like us, they bought items of convenience like us and their culture was not the different to ours.

There is an argument to made that these items were laid in memory of someone, they belonged to someone and they should be left in situ; but that’s a discussion for another blog (or feel free to comment).

These immortelles are the inspiration for not one, but two logos.  The Friends of Arnos Vale logo, and the new amazing new logo created by Bethan Lientie for Life, Death (and the Rest).

AV-LDandR_logo_2018-1-e1515671434876

These items continue to inspire discussion about death, dying and mourning long after they were originally laid in remembrance of a loved one.